Thursday, August 15, 2013

Am I A Jew?


By Alan Caruba

Life is often a series of coincidences and it happened that I had just finished reading “Am I a Jew?” by Theodore Ross when I tuned into the local PBS beg-a-thon featuring two documentaries about being Jewish in America. If you live in the New York City, tri-state area you are not only surrounded by a heavy concentration of Jews, but you absorb their culture by osmosis.

The documentaries were both inspiring and, when it got to the part about the Holocaust—an event within my own lifespan—terrifying. The mind simply cannot come to grips with whole families—millions--killed because they were Jewish.

Ross writes of a childhood in which both parents were Jewish, but when they divorced, his mother took him to Mississippi where she not only hid her religion, but required Ted to attend Christian schools and not speak of being Jewish. He was a Christian in Mississippi and a Jew when he spent time with his father in Manhattan. In truth, he never ceased being Jewish. One supposes that his mother was trying to make life easier for them in a town where being a Jew would have been deemed, shall we say, unusual.

Ross relates that he was never baptized or confirmed or born again. What he lacked, however, was a working knowledge of Judaism.

Ross subtitled his book, “My journey among the believers and pretenders, the lapsed and the lost, in search of faith (not necessarily my own), my roots, and who knows, even myself.” He writes with a light touch and there is humor throughout, but his search is, ultimately everyone’s search; for an identity, a belonging, a purpose.

Or, as Maimonides wrote in The Guide to the Perplexed, “At times the truth shines so brilliantly that we perceive it clear as day. Our nature and our habit then draw a veil over our perception, and we return to a darkness as dense as before. We are like those who, beholding frequent flashes of lightning, still find themselves in the thickest darkness of night.” For those who think Maimonidies is a hospital or university, the original (1325-1204) codified Jewish law in volumes called the Mishna so that Jews of his time could know what was okay and what was not.

Maimonides would not have expressed it in modern terms, but Ross was having an identity crisis and his book was his way of getting through it. The Jews of Maimonides’ era had similar problems and sought similar answers. With no irony intended, Ross was unsure of how to be a Jew.

Not that long ago, Ross had encountered a children’s book, “Abuelita’s Secret Matzahs” about a Hispanic boy named Jacobo, who, visiting his grandmother in Santa Fe, discovered that he was something called an anusim or “Crypto-Jew” which meant that “he was a descendent of the medieval Jews of Spain who were forcibly converted to Catholicism, yet continued, for hundreds of years, to practice Judaism in secret.”

One of those brilliant flashes of light that Maimonides spoke off went off in Ross’s mind and he began to research the topic in New Mexico where he lived and reach out to see if there were other crypto-Jews, living as Christians, but convinced that they were in fact Jews.

The philosophical dilemma that Jews must embrace is that God cannot be known. This is why synagogues have no statues or pictures of God. Among the orthodox, the word isn’t even spelled out in its entirety. A Jew must establish a personal bond, a deep spiritual connection with a God who can only be understood by faith, by understanding the Torah, the law. As for “proof”, Jews routinely refer to God as Lord of the universe. Look around you says the Jew. There’s your proof.

This, of course, is what divides Judaism from most other faiths. One cannot even imagine a Christian church without a cross or a depiction of Jesus suffering crucifixion. The ancients, when visiting a synagogue did not consider Judaism a religion because there were no statues and other depictions of their God. That didn’t save Jews from persecution whether it was the Romans, the Church, or local peasants ready to blame them for the plague or anything else.

In his quest to define himself as Jewish, Ross visited the Jewish Agency in Manhattan in preparation for his “aliyah”, a trip to Israel. He interviewed Misha Galperin who was not sold on the notion that there was one kind of Jew, but referred to “unique populations” of Jews in Israel from locales not traditionally associated with Judaism: Ethiopia, India, Congo, South America, China, the Amazon, and elsewhere, many of whom have been recognized by the Israeli government as Zera Israel or the “seed of Israel.”

To Gasperin, the answer to whether one is a Jew or not is to identify oneself with Jews as a group, an extended family called the Jewish people. “It is a purposeful thing. That’s what our religious heritage is. We have a purpose in the world and we’ve been called upon to persevere and survive because of it…it is hard to understand the survival of the Jewish people without understanding that there is some purpose.”

Those who convert or wish to are occasionally called Jews-by-choice and many, one suspects, are looking for a purpose, one that aligns itself with more than three thousand years of Jewish history and heritage.

In the end, Ross concluded “I am a Jew. I believe that. I am entitled to believe that. I could not make it otherwise even if I wished…for me, both question and answer represent a process of continual, conscious, purposeful becoming.”

As good a definition as any. As the Jewish scholar, Hillel, taught, “Where there are no men, strive to be a man.”

© Alan Caruba, 2013

Wednesday, August 14, 2013

Citizen Journalist

By Alan Caruba

“The beauty of video, especially amplified by the Internet, is to allow a handful of citizen journalists working on a shoestring to end-run the biggest news organizations in the world.”

James O’Keefe, the young man who exposed the corruption within ACORN, an organization whose voter registration program and others were closely allied with the Democratic Party, has written “Breakthrough: Our Guerrilla War to Expose Fraud and Save Democracy.”

Fresh out of college, O’Keefe formed Project Veritas to go after stories that were being ignored by the mainstream press. ACORN gained him national attention when he and a female colleague pretended to be a pimp and a prostitute looking to purchase a home where they could import underage girls for the sex trade. Their hidden camera and microphone recorded the way ACORN employees were unfazed by this and offered advice on how to do it.

O’Keefe was fortunate to secure the late Andrew Breitbart as his mentor and, through him, access to major media personalities and outlets such as Glenn Beck who at the time had a popular show on Fox News. Breitbart was pioneering Internet news gathering and reporting on his own popular website, one element of which was BigGovernment.com.

As PJTV commentator Bill Whittle would note in the wake of the ACORN expose and subsequent legislation that defunded it, “I think the enemy they were fighting against are the media. By not covering the story, not at all…Breitbart showed that the media is no longer merely biased. They’re no longer even ignoring the news. The mainstream media is now in the news suppression business.”

O’Keefe notes that “the New York Times suppresses more stuff, more consequentially, than any other media outlet in the world. Like the Post, the Times tried not to notice the ACORN furor. The newspaper ran its first staff-written article on the subject on September 15, five days after the airing of the initial video and three days after the Post had run its front-page story.” O’Keefe was not even contacted by a Times reporter until two days after its initial story.

The impact of what O’Keefe’s citizen journalism was having was not lost on journalists who make their living within the business. Then executive editor of The New York Times, Bill Keller, would write “Julian Assange (of WikiLeaks) aims to enlist the media; O’Keefe aims to discredit us. But each, in his own guerrilla way, has sown his share of public doubt about whether the press can be trusted as an impartial bearer of news.”

O’Keefe, however, says that “in truth we don’t have the wherewithal to discredit the media. We merely scoop them. They discredit themselves by refusing to cover stories with national implications that much of America already knows to be news.”  The current examples of this are the 2012 Benghazi attack and the Obamacare debacle that continues to unfold with illegal delays, waivers, and its hideous implementation by an already tarnished Internal Revenue Service, involved in its own scandal.

As someone who joined the Society of Professional Journalists on April 1, 1979 and maintained membership ever since, I can attest that journalism over the thirty-five years or more that I have practiced it, has rarely been about being impartial. Indeed, it has gotten worse. Before and since, journalism has largely been an enterprise whose aim has been to advance liberal ideas, liberal legislative initiatives, and those espousing them.

The next time you’re reading the daily newspaper, listening to the radio, or watching television, what you’re not likely to receive is news that will do harm to the progressive agenda. You are receiving the liberal interpretation of what the news is and is not. Were it not for O’Keefe’s efforts you would not have known about ACORN, the deep biases within those running the National Public Radio programming, the attitudes uncovered in the New Jersey Teachers Union, and others.

The response to O’Keefe’s guerrilla journalism has been attacks by those in the news industry to discredit him while reporting on his exposes. He has also been subjected to a bevy a legal suits from those afflicted by the truths he reported. “Although I have been called a liar in a thousand different ways, I have not once been sued for libel or defamation. I have, however, sued others for libeling me. Of course, you would not know that from reading the New York Times.

“The beauty of video, especially as amplified by the Internet,” writes O’Keefe, “is to allow a handful of citizen journalists working on a shoestring to end-run the biggest news organizations in the world. When the American people saw our videos, they responded.”

In the aftermath of the ACORN story, O’Keefe reflected that, “There would be no Pulitzers waiting for us at the end of the day, no speaking engagements at prestigious J-schools. Instead we would face a continuing blizzard of legal challenges, a swarm of snippy media critics, and a tsunami of insider outrage at the slightest accusation of impropriety…It can be brutal along the way, but in the end there is something incredibly beautiful about shoving the facts down the throat of the mainstream media and watching them gag on the truth.”

If you are wondering why President Obama, despite questions about his eligibility to hold office, despite scandals growing like mushrooms, despite his outright lies about Obamacare and the Benghazi attack, continues to go largely unchallenged by the mainstream press, O’Keefe provides a pithy answer. “If today’s reporters found themselves in revolutionary France, they would be endorsing the head choppers, and their audience would cheer each head as it hit the basket.”

© Alan Caruba, 2013

Tuesday, August 13, 2013

It's Not Your Father's Republican Party Anymore

By Alan Caruba

I went out into the rain on Tuesday to vote in the special primary election for the candidates who will oppose one another in November to be New Jersey’s next U.S. Senator. The election was occasioned by the death of Sen. Frank Lautenberg, surely one of the most liberal senators to have ever represented the state.

I was the only one voting in the polling station around midday so it can be said that turnout was low to invisible. I had a nice chat with the election workers who found the idea of a Republican actually living in town something akin to discovering some rare species here.

In New Jersey I think it is safe to say that Gov. Christie will romp to reelection in November. The Democratic Party has put up a sacrificial candidate, Barbara Buono, who virtually no one knows is even running against him. New Jersey is a Democratic state, but the Governor has shown a capacity to attract votes from them. After superstorm Sandy hit, he welcomed President Obama just before the 2012 elections and many Republicans were aghast at how cordial he was. They still are, blaming him in part for Obama’s reelection.

A recent Pew Research Center national survey, conducted July 17-21 among 1,480 adults, including 497 Republican and Republican-leaning voters, asked who they saw as the party’s emerging leadership. While Rep. Paul Ryan who ran for Vice President in the last election had “the most positive image (65%) among GOP voters, Sen. Rand Paul (55%) and Sen. Marco Rubio (50%) ran a close second with Sen. Ted Cruz, most identified with the Tea Party, also did well.

By contrast, Chris Christie, drew “a more mixed reaction among the roughly three-quarters of Republicans who offered an opinion”; 47% viewed him favorably while 30% expressed an unfavorable impression. While Christie’s positions on gun control and the environment may earn Democrat votes should he run for President in 2016, they will cause many Republicans to just stay home if he is the party’s candidate. This happened to Mitt Romney as well.

Based on the Pew Center’s findings, it would appear that the Republican Party is rather sharply divided between its moderates and conservatives. It is fair to say that unless the party can come up with strong leaders with conservative views and programs to offer a way out of the nation’s current economic stagnation and related problems, it is going to have an uphill struggle to get its candidates elected in 2014 and beyond.

So far the party has lost two presidential elections by offering two very squishy candidates, McCain and Romney, who did not ignite strong support among Republicans. Republicans are depressed, but they are also angry and the angriest among them are its Tea Party faction.

“By 54% to 40% Republican and Republican-leaning voters want the party’s leaders to move further to the right,” said the findings of the Pew Center survey. Tea Party Republicans “overwhelmingly favor moving in a more conservative direction, while moderates and liberals would like to see the party take more centrist positions.”

The moderates are a minority within the party and will make up an even smaller share of the likely primary electorate. Republicans who are paying any attention to the 2014 midterm elections want candidates who will take on the Obama administration and Democratic candidates in a vigorous way.

Two issues, immigration and government spending, were top concerns among the Republicans surveyed with most saying the party is not conservative enough by roughly a two-to-one margin. When it comes to government spending, the margin is four-to-one. On gun policy, the majority said the party’s position was about right.

Both Republicans and Democrats have internal tensions. A third of those surveyed from either party thought there was too much compromise with the other, while another third thought they had not compromised enough.
 
The power of the Tea Party movement is often over-stated by political observers. The Pew survey found that “Tea Party Republicans have influence in the GOP partly because of their high level of political engagement. Overall, they make up a minority (37%) of all Republicans and Republican-leaning independents nationally.” The survey noted that “27% of all GOP voters are non-Tea Party conservatives, while 29% are moderates who do not agree with the Tea Party.”

This is, of course, an extrapolation from the survey’s results and is subject to change depending on events and issues in the future.

At the end of the August recess the members of Congress will return and Republican Senators and Representatives will have heard from those who attended their town hall meetings. They are not happy no matter whether they favor Tea Party viewpoints or not, but they are focused on bread-and-butter issues as opposed to conservative views on abortion, gay marriage, and other social issues. That should come as no surprise.

Republicans have been trying to recover from the last two elections that demonstrated the party was doing something wrong. They want its leaders in Congress and in the Party to address the machinations of President Obama, but are frustrated by the fact that the nation’s mainstream press is largely part of the Democratic Party machine. This poses a very big problem for Republicans and independents.

An even bigger problem, however, appears to be the divisions that exist within the Republican Party itself. If the economy does not improve—and it gives little real evidence of doing so—and unemployment remains high, those divisions may narrow in the months ahead that lead up to the midterm elections. If so, the odds will favor Republican candidates.

One thing is sure. The Republican Party today is not your father’s GOP that elected Ronald Reagan in the 1980s. Those halcyon years are over.

© Alan Caruba, 2013

Monday, August 12, 2013

Meteor Dust and My TV Reception


By Alan Caruba

Throughout much of the last two days my Direct TV reception, fed via satellite, was disrupted as some stations were accessible while others were not. Turned out to be just an outage problem for my apartment complex, but I initially wondered if it might have to do with lots and lots of meteoric dust.

Here’s why: on August 11th and 12th the annual Perseid meteor showers were at their peak. They are commonly called shooting stars and can be quite stunning. They are, as Karen C. Fox noted on NASA.gov, only “the tip of the iceberg when it comes to meteoroids slamming into Earth’s atmosphere. Some 10 to 40 tons of material of invisible meteoric dust enters the atmosphere from interplanetary space every day.”

And you were worried because Al Gore has been ranting about a little bit of carbon dioxide (CO2), a mere 0.038 percent of the atmosphere, was going to destroy the Earth?

Here’s what Steven Goddard, the proprietor of the Real Science blog, noted on Saturday, August 10, after hearing that CO2 now constituted 400 parts per million in the atmosphere:

# Coldest summer on record at the North Pole
# Highest August Arctic ice extent since 2006
# Record high August Antarctic ice extent
# No major hurricane strikes for eight years
# Slowest tornado season on record
# No global warming for 17 years
# Second slowest fire season on record
# Four of the five snowiest northern hemisphere winters have occurred since 2008

At some point people have to understand that all talk of CO2 having anything to do with the weather and/or climate is a huge lie. And all those schemes and laws intended to reduce CO2 emissions are lies as well.

Take a moment and think about all the other environmental things you are supposed to worry about. Rising sea levels—not happening. Melting glaciers—not happening. Disappearing rain forests—not happening. And on and on with an endless list that all require billions in government funds to research and billions more wasted on solutions that solve nothing.

Happily, no one fears meteor showers. As Ms. Fox reported, “The big showers like the Perseids, and later the Leonids in November, are caused when Earth and its atmosphere travels through a region of the sky filled with left over debris lost by a particular comet.” This dust “ploughs into Earth’s atmosphere at speeds of between 7 to 44 miles per second. They also bring with them minerals and metals from their parent bodies, such as sodium, silicon, calcium, and magnesium.”

John Millis, Ph.D., is an assistant professor of physics and astronomy at Anderson University, in Anderson Indiana. He teaches a wide variety of courses while maintaining an active research program in high energy astrophysics. Some time ago I printed out an article he authored, “A History of Massive Solar Storms.” Those who think that a little CO2 in the atmosphere is a threat to all life on Earth should try to wrap their minds around the prospect of a really big solar storm.

“Should a solar storm erupt in the coming years,” wrote Dr. Mallis, “it will release a massive amount of high energy charged particles streaming toward Earth. Such a storm occurred in 1859.”

The good news is that a sign of such a solar storm is an increase in sun spot activity and, right now, there is negligible sun spot activity. Scratch it off your worry list. However, low sun spot activity—magnetic storms on the sun’s surface—is the reason the Earth has been in a cooling cycle for some 17 years. We are not going to be hit with a huge solar storm, but we could be on the cusp of the next Ice Age.

The late American poet, Robert Frost, wrote:

Some say the world will end in fire,
Some say in ice.
From what I've tasted of desire
I hold with those who favor fire.
But if it had to perish twice,
I think I know enough of hate
To say that for destruction ice
Is also great
And would suffice.

That’s not only great poetry, but pretty good science as well.

© Alan Caruba, 2013

Sunday, August 11, 2013

Abandoning the Middle East


By Alan Caruba

A map of the U.S. embassies and consulates throughout the Middle East and Northern Africa tells you everything need to know about Barack Obama’s failed foreign policy. It is worth noting that Britain and France also choose to close many of their diplomatic posts. The West which has had a long history of coveting and controlling elements of the Middle East and the African continent is in retreat.

It is historic and it speaks to the shrinking of their power to intervene and influence events in this vast region of the world. It is also so dangerous that contemplating the outcome is frightening.

Despite President Obama’s belief that “all wars have to come to an end”, the reality is that we are locked into a long war with the forces of Islamism, the most dangerous threat to civilization the world has seen since the last century.

As we have learned, al Qaeda is not “on the run” even if bin Laden is dead. His close associate, Ayman al-Zawahiri, formerly associated with the Muslim Brotherhood, is very much alive and there appears to be an entire new generation of Muslims who have taken up the flag to wage war on the West and to conquer Middle Eastern nations run by a variety of despots and monarchs.

These wars have been going on for a long time. They date back to the establishment of al Qaeda in the 1980s and the Muslim Brotherhood in 1928. I suspect the closing of U.S. embassies as Ramadan ends is going to become a standard precaution in the years ahead.

Algeria faced the Islamist threat from 1991 to 2002 and its military was engaged in a bloody conflict with tens of thousands of casualties until the Islamists surrendered. Today it is Syria that is slaughtering its own dissidents along with a flow of Islamists from the region that include Hezbollah out of Lebanon, fighters out of Chechnya, and military assistance from Iran, among others.

President Obama actually thought he could personally reset the relations between the U.S. and Muslim nations, but he was either delusional and/or a poor student of history. No doubt he assumed that the national weariness with wars in Iraq and Afghanistan would make it easy to pull out our military forces without any serious consequences. However, this was interpreted as weakness by Islamists and rightly so.

What is surprising and disturbing is that our intelligence agencies and advisors to the President have been so wrong, so consistently. Al Qaeda and other elements of the Islamist movement are not on the run; they are growing in strength and reach.

Like Democrat Presidents before him Carter and Clinton, Obama has engaged in hollowing out the U.S. military, leaving the nation at greater peril in an always dangerous world.

It could be that leaders in the West have concluded that the reach of al Qaeda and related Islamist groups is so vast that it is too costly to maintain the force levels in the Middle East and elsewhere to project power and influence events. Two U.S. carrier groups used to be stationed in the Persian Gulf. Now there is one.

The swiftness with which former dictators in Tunisia, Libya, and Egypt were overthrown no doubt took the West by surprise. The ability of the Syrian regime to hold out in its civil war is another example. The military forces in Middle Eastern nations hold the key to the future and they will determine what it will be.

The good news is that there are secular Muslims in the Middle East that do not want to live under Sharia law. The bad news is that they are not organized and Islamists have no problem with killing them. This is a struggle that will play out very slowly.

Meanwhile, the West has been sidelined. It is now a spectator, not a shaper of the outcome.

© Alan Caruba, 2013

Saturday, August 10, 2013

The Tip Jar is Empty!

I am beginning to think that the donations that “Warning Signs” receives are as good an economic indicator as anything you will read about the Dow Jones or Standard and Poors’ statistical data. The year started strongly, but as of August the Tip Jar is almost empty!

The content on the Internet is “free” but the fact is that someone must create it and, in the case of this blog, that means a lot of research to ensure you receive the best information and the time it takes to evaluate it in order to provide the insight you need to understand what is happening in a very complex world. Meanwhile, there’s the rent and groceries for the dinner table.
So, if you are among the many people who visit this blog regularly then you need to send something to help maintain it. As little as $10 or as much as you can spare will be very helpful and very appreciated.